The Castle Church Door

In this post, Victor Reppert asked for some clarification. Ask and you shall receive.Steve Hays gave some answers. He wrote,"This is simpleminded. God would be just in damning everyone *because* everyone is a sinner. The justice of this counterfactual is indexed to a necessary condition. God would be just in saving everyone *if* Christ died for everyone. The justice of that counterfactual is indexed to a necessary condition. ...

A few atheists sites have been lauding this "letter" to God:i) I didn't know atheists wished Hitler and Jeffery Dahmer were still walking around among us.ii) Perhaps this will help: No one "dies". You're just leaving your earthly stage of life. You will live forever (see Q/A. 19). So, don't worry, no one ceases to exist. Where you exist is another matter altogether.